◆ Not affiliated with the City of Toronto ◆ Very affiliated with your dog ◆ Made to order ◆

06 · Policy Worth Reviewing

Six rules
worth a 2nd look.

None of these require loving every dog. They're places where Toronto's own system is all-or-nothing, undefined, or invisible — which hurts owners with good dogs and doesn't protect anyone from the bad ones.

01

The Tribunal can only say yes or no

Today
The Dangerous Dog Review Tribunal can confirm an order or cancel it. Nothing in between. In 2022 staff opposed letting it tailor conditions (DDRT 2021 report).
Why it bites
A dog that needs a muzzle but not a public map pin gets both, or neither. All-or-nothing pushes people into fights they'd otherwise settle.
Elsewhere
In Massachusetts, a hearing authority picks from a menu of conditions and a court can review the whole thing fresh (M.G.L. c. 140, § 157). In B.C., the Santics ruling left judges stuck with a similar binary, and animal-law commentators criticize it for exactly that.
The ask
Let the Tribunal vary conditions, not just confirm or cancel.

02

"Severe" isn't defined

Today
A severe act skips the warning and goes straight to a lifetime order. The bylaw doesn't say what severe means. In 2025 staff advised against defining it (Mar 2025).
Why it bites
The biggest decision in the process rests on one officer's judgment, with no published test to argue against.
The ask
Publish the severity criteria officers actually use.

03

Orders never end

Today
Every condition lasts for the dog's life. There's no review, no matter how many clean years follow.
Why it bites
A dog that bit once as an under-socialized adolescent wears it at 12. No incentive to keep training beyond the first 90 days.
The ask
A path to apply for review after a clean record and a behaviour assessment.

04

Appeals are disappearing

Today
35 hearings in 2023, 8 in 2025. The fee was $374 in 2023. The Tribunal's own Chair asked whether the system is suppressing appeals (Mar 2026).
Why it bites
If people stop appealing because it costs too much or can't change anything, the drop tells you nothing about whether orders are right.
The ask
Find out why. Survey people who got orders and didn't appeal.

05

Decisions aren't published

Today
Tribunal decisions aren't on CanLII. You can't read how past appeals were argued or decided without an FOI request.
Why it bites
Owners walk in blind. Victims can't see consistency either.
The ask
Publish anonymized decisions.

06

Your postal code on a map

Today
Severe cases show the full six-character postal code on the public map. City staff advised against it; Council did it anyway.
Why it bites
In much of Toronto a full postal code narrows to one building or a few houses. That's an address, permanently tied to the worst day of someone's life. There's no evidence yet that it prevents bites.
The ask
Report on whether the map changes anything. If it doesn't, roll it back to the first three characters.

Not Toronto's call

The pit bull ban

Ontario still bans pit bull-type dogs by appearance, on top of Toronto's behaviour-based rules. That's the provincial Dog Owners' Liability Act, so City Council can't touch it. Only Queen's Park can.

The dogs most often under Toronto orders are German shepherds, American bulldogs and Labs, not pit bulls (Toronto Life). Toronto laid 5 pit bull charges in 2022–2024 combined.

Want it gone? That's a separate paper petition to the Legislature. Not part of the Toronto one.

Where we're not neutral

We sell merch to people whose dogs got labelled. We say so. Every claim on this page links to the document it came from so you can check us. If we got something wrong, tell us.

How to push on any of these →
Data as of October 2026 · latest City source: June 23, 2026 report to Council.
Not affiliated with the City of Toronto or Toronto Animal Services. Every number links to the City document it came from.
All sources →   Spotted an error? →
Soundtrack

The Bad Dog Anthem

Open in Spotify

Plays through Spotify. Sign in to Spotify for full tracks; otherwise you'll hear 30-second previews.