01
The Tribunal can only say yes or no
- Today
- The Dangerous Dog Review Tribunal can confirm an order or cancel it. Nothing in between. In 2022 staff opposed letting it tailor conditions (DDRT 2021 report).
- Why it bites
- A dog that needs a muzzle but not a public map pin gets both, or neither. All-or-nothing pushes people into fights they'd otherwise settle.
- Elsewhere
- In Massachusetts, a hearing authority picks from a menu of conditions and a court can review the whole thing fresh (M.G.L. c. 140, § 157). In B.C., the Santics ruling left judges stuck with a similar binary, and animal-law commentators criticize it for exactly that.
- The ask
- Let the Tribunal vary conditions, not just confirm or cancel.