◆ Not affiliated with the City of Toronto ◆ Very affiliated with your dog ◆ Made to order ◆

The Bad Dog DispatchCase Files edition

Case Files

Luna. Border Collie. Strike three.

A puppy nip, a trespasser, and one bad morning. Luna's on strike three and wears the City's red tag. The third one was my fault, not hers.

Luna, a black and white Border Collie, lying in a patch of blue scilla flowers in a Toronto park

Dog: Luna, Border Collie, spayed female, 8
Neighbourhood: East End
Strikes: 3
What the City did: Dangerous Dog Order. She wears the red tag.
Filed by: Rahul, her owner. Also the guy who started Bad Dog Supply Co. So yes, this one's personal.

Strike one

She was six months old. A jogger went by, puppy brain did puppy things, and she nipped him.

Strike two

A guy came onto our property and started going through our recycling. Luna bit him.

Strike three

October 2025. A hectic morning. Kids to get out the door, lunches, something on the stove, a conference to get to. I gave myself 15 minutes to run her.

I took her to a cemetery near us that's on-leash only, unclipped her and threw a ball. Once. Then I looked up. It was way busier than usual.

By the time I went to clip her back on, she was a row over and had spotted another dog, on leash, with her owner. Luna didn't come back when I called. She went for the other dog. The other dog got hurt.

Whose fault

That one's mine. 100%. She was off leash where she shouldn't have been because I was in a rush.

I told the other owner on the spot, paid the full vet bill within 48 hours, and left a note with my number the next morning. We dropped off a care package and still check in when we see them.

What the City did

Strike three gets a Dangerous Dog Order. Muzzle off our property, a sign, the red City tag, no off-leash parks, an approved training course. For the rest of her life (the full list).

I wrote to the officer, owned it, and asked whether a muzzled, trained dog could still use off-leash areas.

What changed

  • Luna is muzzle trained and wears a basket muzzle on public walks.
  • She's on leash anywhere that isn't a designated off-leash area. No exceptions.

Context, not an excuse: she'd had a rough year, coming back from CCL (knee ligament) surgery. She goes on off-leash pack walks with a pro walker and has never had a problem there.

Luna as a Border Collie puppy, sitting in violets in a black harness
Exhibit A: the defendant, pre-strike one.
Exhibit B: the defendant, asking how you are. Sound on.

What I'd tell Council

Strike three was on me. The order went on her.

Let a muzzled, trained dog use off-leash areas. Border Collies need to run. Keep a high-drive dog cooped up for life and you're not making anyone safer.

The longer version, and why I got her tag tattooed on my arm: There are no bad dogs, only bad dog owners.

Got a file of your own? Tell it here.

Soundtrack

The Bad Dog Anthem

Open in Spotify

Plays through Spotify. Sign in to Spotify for full tracks; otherwise you'll hear 30-second previews.